Head-to-head · Best Chef Knives

Hedley & Bennett Chef's Knife vs Mac MTH-80

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

Verdict is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our ratings are sourced from independent publications, not sponsors.

The short answer

Mac MTH-80 comes out ahead by a clear margin (4.8 vs 4.0). The gap is mostly about experienced cooks seeking maximum precision and speed in fine cuts — read the strengths below before deciding.

Ranked #6 in Best Chef Knives

Hedley & Bennett Chef's Knife

4.0

4 sourcesall derived$109.62as of Oct 3

The Hedley & Bennett Chef’s Knife features a lightweight 0.4-pound design and an eight-inch AUS10 steel core that delivers high edge retention, making it ideal for reducing hand fatigue during extended prep work. The Kitchn found the blade arrives wicked-sharp with a convex grind that slices cleanly through delicate produce without crushing them. Will Stelter noted that while the ergonomic handle fits various hand sizes comfortably, visible scratches on the pins and uneven bolster transitions detract from its premium fit and finish. At $115, this mid-tier option suits cooks prioritizing performance over flawless aesthetics, but budget-conscious buyers or those demanding perfect cosmetic quality should look elsewhere.

Strengths

— Lightweight construction (0.4 lbs) reduces hand fatigue during extended prep work
— Three-layer Japanese steel core with AUS10 material provides high edge retention and durability
— Ergonomic handle design features a neutral curvature that fits various hand sizes comfortably

Watch-outs

— Fit and finish issues include visible scratches on pins and uneven bolster transitions
— Mid-tier price point ($115) may be prohibitive for budget-conscious home cooks

$109.62 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Higher ratedRanked #1 in Best Chef Knives

Mac MTH-80

4.8

4 sources3 derived$175as of Oct 3

techgearlab found the Mac MTH-80 to be the sharpest knife in their lineup, capable of performing the finest chiffonades and smallest onion dice. isaaccarew reported excellent edge retention lasting weeks of restaurant prep, significantly outperforming German blades due to its VG-10 steel core and 60 HRC hardness. The blade geometry is nearly flawless with a thin profile that glides through food with almost no resistance, while the balance point sits exactly at the bolster to prevent wrist fatigue during long sessions. However, the thin blade is too fragile to lever bones or split hard vegetables like butternut squash without chipping. Additionally, the notably short handle requires a specific pinch grip, making it unsuitable for inexperienced users who prefer heavier Western-style knives. The knife must be hand-washed only as the dishwasher will pit the blade within a month. This model fits experienced cooks seeking precision and speed, while those needing durability or ease of use should look elsewhere.

Strengths

— GearLab found it to be the sharpest knife in their lineup, capable of performing the finest chiffonades and smallest onion dice.
— The blade geometry is described as nearly flawless with a thin profile that glides through food with almost no resistance.
— Isaac Carew reported excellent edge retention lasting weeks of restaurant prep, significantly outperforming German blades.

Watch-outs

— The thin blade is too fragile to lever bones or split hard vegetables like butternut squash without chipping.
— The handle is notably short and requires a specific pinch grip, making it unsuitable for inexperienced users.
— The knife must be hand-washed only as the dishwasher will pit the blade.

$175 · Buy at macknife.com Full review →

Derived means the reviewer published no score, so one was inferred from their written verdict. Everything else is a number the publisher printed. How we rank.

How they stack up

Hedley & Bennett Chef's Knife

The Hedley & Bennett Chef's Knife distinguishes itself with a lightweight 0.4 lb design that reduces hand fatigue, whereas the Mercer Culinary Genesis is significantly heavier and built for rigidity during heavy chopping tasks. While both offer ergonomic handles, the Hedley & Bennett features an AUS10 core steel compared to the Mac MTH-80's VG-10 core, offering a different balance of edge retention and durability against the sharper but more fragile Japanese options.

Mac MTH-80

The Mac MTH-80 is noted for its exceptional sharpness and thin profile that glides through food with almost no resistance, making it superior to the thicker Mercer Culinary Genesis for precision slicing. However, unlike the Hedley & Bennett Chef's Knife which offers a neutral handle fit for various hand sizes, the Mac MTH-80 has a notably short handle that requires a specific pinch grip and is unsuitable for inexperienced users.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Hedley & Bennett Chef's Knife	Mac MTH-80
Blade Length	8 in	8 inches
Steel Type	Three Layer Japanese Steel (AUS10 core)	VG-10 core / AUS-8 variant
Hardness	60 HRC	60 HRC
Total Length	12.8 in	12.63 inches
Weight	0.4 lbs	6.4 oz
Handle Material	Caviar Black	Pakkawood
Edge Angle	23 degrees per side	15 degrees
Construction	Three Layer Japanese Steel	Stamped

← See the full ranking of best chef knives