Head-to-head · Best Roof Top Tents

Thule Approach M vs Topoak Galaxy 1.0

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

Verdict is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our ratings are sourced from independent publications, not sponsors.

The short answer

Thule Approach M comes out ahead by a clear margin (4.7 vs 4.0). The gap is mostly about Campers prioritizing luxurious sleep comfort and robust build quality — read the strengths below before deciding.

Higher ratedRanked #2 in Best Roof Top Tents

Thule Approach M

4.7

7 sources1 derived$99.95as of Oct 2

The Thule Approach M delivers a luxurious sleeping experience with cavernous interior space and a thick dual-density foam mattress that comfortably fits two adults and a pet, as GearJunkie found. Its robust construction features an aluminum base and 600D polyester canopy, while Downtown-Mag praised the convenient bayonet lock mounting system for simplifying attachment to roof bars without complex hardware. However, the tent weighs 128 pounds, requiring two people for initial installation, and multiple reviewers noted that setting up the rainfly is challenging due to difficult tension rod placement. This rooftop tent suits campers prioritizing comfort and build quality over quick setup ease, while those seeking a lighter or faster-to-deploy option should look elsewhere.

Strengths

— Outstanding interior space and comfort with a spacious footprint that accommodates two adults and a child or dog, featuring a thick dual-density foam mattress.
— High-quality construction using robust materials including an aluminum base, 600D polyester canopy, and burly zippers that reviewers describe as bomber.
— Quick setup time of under three minutes once installed on the vehicle, with simple ladder deployment and fabric unfolding.

Watch-outs

— The travel cover completely separates from the tent body during use, requiring storage in the vehicle rather than stowing on the rack.
— Installation of the rainfly is described as challenging and frustrating by multiple reviewers due to tension rod placement.
— Significant weight (128 lbs / 58 kg) requires two people for initial roof installation.

$99.95 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Ranked #4 in Best Roof Top Tents

Topoak Galaxy 1.0

4.0

4 sources1 derived$1,818as of Oct 2

The Topoak Galaxy 1.0 features a burly aluminum alloy hardshell that gearjunkie found offers weatherproofing comparable to much more expensive tents, while its unique U-shaped internal bar expands the sleeping footprint by approximately 35 percent for better interior volume. The unit deploys rapidly in roughly 30 seconds using gas-charged struts and includes amenities like a two-inch memory foam mattress and LED lighting with remote control. However, the heavy weight ranging from 165 to 176 pounds requires a vehicle with high dynamic load capacity and typically two people for installation, and bikerumor criticized the locking buckles as wonky with minimal theft deterrence. This rooftop tent fits families seeking quick setup and spacious interiors but should be avoided by those prioritizing security or lightweight portability.

Strengths

— Aluminum alloy hardshell construction provides a burly feel and weather resistance comparable to tents costing twice as much.
— U-shaped internal bar expands the sleeping footprint by approximately 35%, offering significantly more interior volume than standard wedge-style rooftop tents.
— Includes high-value amenities such as a 2-inch memory foam mattress, LED lighting with remote control, exterior shoe bags, and six suspended storage pockets.

Watch-outs

— Heavy weight ranging from 165 to 176 lbs requires a vehicle with high dynamic load capacity and typically two people for installation.
— Locking buckles on the hardshell use low-security keys that reviewers described as wonky, offering minimal theft deterrence.
— Included handwheels for mounting brackets can loosen easily during transit, prompting some users to upgrade to Nylock nuts.

$1,818 · Buy at topoakoverland.com Full review →

Derived means the reviewer published no score, so one was inferred from their written verdict. Everything else is a number the publisher printed. How we rank.

How they stack up

Thule Approach M

The Thule Approach M provides a thicker dual-density foam mattress for superior comfort compared to the SanHima Hotham's thin memory foam option. While it shares similar weight constraints with the Rugged Ridge Outland, its bayonet lock mounting system simplifies installation on roof bars more effectively than the finicky locking nuts often associated with heavy hard-shell setups.

Topoak Galaxy 1.0

The Topoak Galaxy 1.0 expands its sleeping footprint by approximately 35% using a U-shaped internal bar, offering significantly more interior volume than the standard wedge-style designs of the SanHima Hotham or Thule Approach M. Although it shares rapid gas-strut deployment with the SanHima model, reviewers note its locking buckles are less secure and prone to loosening compared to the integrated security features found on other hard-shell competitors.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Thule Approach M	Topoak Galaxy 1.0
Weight	128 lb	172 lb
Closed Dimensions	49 x 56 x 11 in	83 x 56 x 8 in
Open Dimensions	95 x 56 x 40 in	83 x 56 x 53 in
Mattress Type	Dual-density foam	2-inch-thick high-density foam mattress
Material	Cotton	Aluminum Alloy
Capacity	—	two adults and a child
Dimensions	—	83"L x 56"W x 53"H

← See the full ranking of best roof top tents