Head-to-head · Best Smart Scales

Withings Body Comp Smart Scale vs Withings Body Smart

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

Verdict is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our ratings are sourced from independent publications, not sponsors.

The short answer

Withings Body Comp Smart Scale comes out ahead by a narrow margin (3.9 vs 3.8). The gap is mostly about health-conscious premium buyers — read the strengths below before deciding.

Higher ratedRanked #3 in Best Smart Scales

Withings Body Comp Smart Scale

3.9

6 sources$129.95as of Aug 1

The Withings Body Comp gathers a lot of data: muscle, fat, and bone mass, plus heart rate and vascular age. iMore praised the sleek design and the breadth of health insights while noting that full functionality requires a subscription. Tom's Guide called it a 'beautiful-looking smart scale' capable of delivering more measurements than most users will need. Health-conscious buyers who want detail are the fit; anyone on a budget or with minimal health tracking needs will find cheaper options that do enough.

Strengths

— Measures up to 20+ body composition metrics including muscle mass, fat mass, and bone mass
— Features a good-sized color screen that displays multiple health insights at once
— Includes standing heart rate and vascular age tracking for cardiovascular health monitoring

Watch-outs

— Full Withings Health+ experience requires a paid subscription
— Expensive at $189.95, placing it in the premium smart scale category

$129.95 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

Ranked #5 in Best Smart Scales

Withings Body Smart

3.8

5 sources$129.95as of Aug 1

The Withings Body Smart is a Wi-Fi scale whose distinguishing feature is a mode that refuses to show a number. Reviews range from 3.5 to 4.1 out of 5: PCMag and Tom's Guide rate the body-composition detail and the app's explanations of it, The Verge spent three months with Eyes-Closed Mode and found it changed the daily ritual, and Tech Advisor is blunt that bioelectrical impedance analysis is inherently flawed. It suits people who want trends and context, not a precision instrument.

Strengths

— Accurately measures multiple health metrics including weight, body fat percentage, and muscle mass
— Seamlessly syncs data to smartphone app and Withings Health Mate platform for easy tracking
— Provides detailed body composition analysis with visual progress charts and trends

Watch-outs

— Requires manual user registration for each person using the scale
— Limited compatibility with third-party health apps outside of Withings ecosystem
— Battery life reportedly decreases significantly after extended use

$129.95 · Check Price on Amazon Full review →

How they stack up

Withings Body Comp Smart Scale

The Withings Body Comp offers more comprehensive body composition metrics than the Wyze Scale X, Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale, and Renpho Elis Chroma Aspire Smart Scale, but it's significantly more expensive and requires a subscription. Compared to the Withings Body Smart, it provides more detailed health insights but lacks the manual user registration convenience.

Withings Body Smart

The Withings Body Smart provides accurate body composition tracking like the Wyze Scale X but lacks the RGB lighting and compact design of the Renpho Elis Chroma Aspire Smart Scale. While it offers detailed analytics and seamless smartphone integration, it doesn't include the cardiovascular health metrics or nerve health assessment found in the Withings Body Comp.

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Withings Body Comp Smart Scale	Withings Body Smart
Connectivity	Wi-Fi, Bluetooth	Wi-Fi, Bluetooth
Weight Capacity	441 lb	350 lb
Metrics	Body composition, heart rate, vascular age, nerve health	Weight, Body Fat, Muscle Mass
Users Supported	Up to 8	8
Battery Type	4 x AAA	4 AA batteries

← See the full ranking of best smart scales