Head-to-head · Best Flat Top Griddles

Steelfire 22 vs Weber Slate 36" Rust-Resistant Griddle

Which is the better buy? Side-by-side on rating, price, strengths, and watch-outs — with the published ratings we averaged to get there.

Verdict is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our ratings are sourced from independent publications, not sponsors.

The short answer

Weber Slate 36" Rust-Resistant Griddle comes out ahead by a clear margin (4.8 vs 4.5). The gap is mostly about Users prioritizing long-term durability and reduced maintenance on their cooking surface — read the strengths below before deciding.

Ranked #3 in Best Flat Top Griddles

Steelfire 22

4.5

4 sources2 derived

The Steelfire 22 heats from cold to searing temperatures in approximately seven minutes, reaching over 460°F quickly thanks to its single 14,000-BTU racetrack burner. The Barbecue Lab found that the three-ply 304 stainless steel surface resists rust and eliminates cold corners, though it requires no seasoning unlike traditional griddles. However, the oval shape lacks defined zones, making food placement less intuitive than rectangular designs, and users must purchase a separate long-nipple adapter to connect to standard 20-lb propane tanks. This portable tabletop unit fits campers seeking quick searing on stainless steel but may frustrate those accustomed to traditional griddle layouts or bulk fuel connections.

Strengths

— Heats from cold to searing temperatures in approximately seven minutes, reaching over 460°F quickly.
— Features a three-ply 304 stainless steel cooking surface that resists rust and requires no seasoning.
— Racetrack burner layout provides even edge-to-edge heating for consistent cooking results.

Watch-outs

— Oval shape lacks corners and defined zones, which can make food placement less intuitive than rectangular griddles.
— Includes only a single burner with lower total BTU output compared to the larger 30-inch model.
— Requires purchasing a separate long-nipple adapter to connect to standard 20-lb propane tanks.

Buy at scheels.com Full review →

Higher ratedRanked #1 in Best Flat Top Griddles

Weber Slate 36" Rust-Resistant Griddle

4.8

4 sources1 derived

The Weber Slate 36 features a case-hardened carbon steel cooktop that Grillpicker found genuinely resists rust, addressing common durability issues in budget models. It delivers 48,000 BTUs across four independent burners and includes an enclosed cabinet for weather-protected storage. However, the unit costs roughly double comparable mid-range options and requires up to two hours of assembly due to numerous cart panels. Additionally, the built-in digital thermometer reads only one spot and can disagree with infrared measurements by 30-50°F. This griddle fits users prioritizing long-term durability and reduced maintenance, while occasional cooks may prefer cheaper alternatives.

Strengths

— Case-hardened carbon steel cooktop is pre-seasoned and marketed as rust-resistant, addressing a common flaw in competitor models.
— Built-in digital temperature gauge allows users to monitor cooktop heat without using external tools.
— Enclosed cabinet storage keeps propane tanks and grilling accessories protected from weather.

Watch-outs

— Premium pricing is approximately double that of comparable mid-range flat-top griddles.
— Assembly involves numerous cart panels and screws, commonly taking up to two hours to complete.
— Digital thermometer reads only one spot on the cooktop and can disagree with infrared measurements by 30-50°F.

Buy at weber.com Full review →

Derived means the reviewer published no score, so one was inferred from their written verdict. Everything else is a number the publisher printed. How we rank.

How they stack up

Steelfire 22

The Steelfire 22 distinguishes itself with a three-ply 304 stainless steel surface that requires no seasoning, unlike the carbon steel surfaces of the Traeger Flatrock or Weber Slate 30 Inch Griddle. It is significantly lighter (~38 lbs) and more portable than all other listed griddles, though it offers only a single burner compared to the multi-burner configurations of competitors like the Blackstone Omnivore 28-inch.

Weber Slate 36" Rust-Resistant Griddle

This griddle features a case-hardened carbon steel cooktop that Grillpicker found genuinely resists rust, addressing the maintenance issues common to the Traeger Flatrock and Blackstone Omnivore 28-inch. It provides 48,000 BTUs across four independent burners, offering more power than the Weber Slate 30 Inch Griddle (36,000 BTUs) but less than the Blackstone 36 Air Fryer Combo (60,000 BTUs).

Specs side-by-side

Spec	Steelfire 22	Weber Slate 36" Rust-Resistant Griddle
Surface Material	304 Stainless Steel	Rust-resistant carbon steel
Burner Configuration	Racetrack (Single)	4 independent burners
BTU Output	14,000-BTU	48,000 BTUs
Cooking Area	321.7 sq in	756 sq in
Fuel Type	Propane	Propane / Natural Gas
Max Temperature	460°+ range	—
Weight	~38 lbs	198 lbs
Material	—	Rust-resistant carbon-steel

← See the full ranking of best flat top griddles